Blown account
Why do I keep blowing accounts
Goal
On a replay the chart waits. You can think, practice the pullback, run it again, and read the rows. The loss stays in the journal. Live, the account has to get through that same losing streak.
The chain
A pullback on GBPUSD after the London open is the example. You replay one week with the next candle hidden. You take it only when it is the pullback that the written rule names, and that trade gets a row.
A losing day stays in the journal. The next row doesn't have to follow in the same minute, and the next trade doesn't have to win that loss back. You don't blow the account on that replay.
Then you trade that pullback live. The candle is moving. The setup name isn't written, and the order is already in. Each loser comes faster than the last. The account is blown.
Write the setup name and the risk before you send the order. If the candle leaves before the note is done, skip the trade.
The note can still be the wrong trade. It says "pullback" for a dip that doesn't reach the level. Weeks ago you skipped that dip on a replay. Today you take it.
Practice the setup again before the live week. The note has to match a row from that replay.
You do that once, and then you stop. Next week you don't open the replay. The note is a word that you type while the candle moves, and you take the dip that doesn't reach the level.
Put the replay on the calendar every week, on the dates that you write down before you open the chart. A week that you don't finish keeps the live size off.
You move the start to a week that you remember as clean. The losing days don't get replayed.
Start at a date that you don't choose, inside the dates that you write down. A TestingView session can pick that start (ChronoShuffle).
You can still quit while the journal is green. The ugly pullback later in the week hasn't been replayed, and the live size is still on. You meet that pullback for the first time with the account open.
The week counts only when you finish the dates that you write down.
A skip that you don't write down gets taken live. On that week the same dip looks like the pullback, and you take it. Give the skip a row in that replay too.
You open the journal at the winners. The losers sit at the bottom, and the live week starts as if that streak wasn't there. Read the losers before the winners.
A live loser has left the account. You raise the next size to get it back. The streak that the journal already held now blows the account, because each trade in it is larger.
Copy the risk from the replay before you start. A loss doesn't change it.
The size can be right and the trade still wrong. The candle looks clear. On the replay, the rest of the move would still be hidden. This isn't the pullback that the rule names, and you fill it anyway. The account is blown on trades that the written rule didn't name.
After the week, put the live fills next to the replay rows. A fill that isn't on that list keeps the live size off until the next finished week matches. Do it while the account is still open.
Takeaways
- Write the setup name and the risk before the order. If the candle leaves first, skip it.
- Before the live week, the note has to match a row from the replay.
- An unfinished week keeps the live size off.
- Start at a date that you don't choose, inside the dates that you write down. A week that you remember as clean doesn't get picked.
- A green journal that stopped early doesn't count. Finish the dates that you wrote down.
- A skip gets a row. A dip that you passed doesn't get taken on the live week.
- Read the losers before the winners.
- Copy the risk before you start. A loss doesn't raise it.
- After the week, an extra fill turns the live size off.
What the story leaves out
You wouldn't build the routine by waiting for the account to blow. You write the pause down when you set the week up, before the first live order.
The fills and the replay rows have to be the same dates. A replay of a different week doesn't show the extra trades.
One finished week doesn't show that the pullback has an edge. The numbers post covers expectancy on a longer journal.
The live results post covers what happens when the weekly replay stops and the account is the only record of new prices.
Starter caps a session at 20 trades. Explorer caps it at 50. A week that should include a losing streak may not fit in that cap. Trader doesn't cap the trades in a session.
TestingView records the replay. It doesn't pull fills from a broker. You bring the live fills yourself.
A funded account can close on a loss that is smaller than the streak in the journal.
Next week's prices aren't in this week's replay.